Argumentative fallacies have an unfortunate tendency to rebound on the person who employs them, and the fallacy that rebounds the most energetically and does the most damage in the process is the Straw Man.
The Straw Man fallacy gets its name from the dummies used as targets in combat training. Obviously, bayonetting a straw man is easier than bayonetting a real one, who might object to the procedure and fight back. In argument, it is easier to make up a silly or inadequate argument to rebut rather than to rebut the actual argument of one's opponent.
The problem with misrepresenting an opponent's argument is that the opponent knows what his argument was and can easily cry foul. People will think you're either a cheat--and a poor cheat at that--or simpy an idiot.
I make this point because the Straw Man fallacy has become one of the favorite tactics of many online debaters. As a result, people argue past rather than with one another, and that is one of the real intellectual tragedies of our polity.
I had a craving for pancakes this morning. Pancakes slathered in butter and dripping with boysenberry syrup, surrounded by plump, juicy sausages along with a nice steaming hot cup o’ non-designer Joe; black, like my heart. So of course I jumped in my Cherokee and headed for IHOP.
Eventually I got my pancakes just the way I like ‘em but before I did I had to sit and listen to the following exchange between the President of the Senile Breakfast Club and the young waiter trying to get everyone’s order down as quickly as possible. The point of this piece is to illustrate once again why I do not like being around other people , most especially OLD people.
[dialogue between a young waiter and the silver haired human model for the Foghorn Leghorn cartoon character on WB, dressed in white with the belly supported by white suspenders with the slow southern drawl and all..]
Waiter: Good morning sir. Are you ready to order ?
Foghorn: ..... Ahhhhemm... Hockeypucks..
Waiter: ????
Foghorn: ......
Waiter: “Hockeypucks” ?
Foghorn: ....Yes. Are you familiar with ‘Hockypucks’ ?
Waiter: [looking genuinely confused at this point]
Old voice from the back of the room: [in a whisper] Psst... He means sausage.
Waiter: Oh! Sausage ! Yes, we have sausage. Is that what you’d like ?
Foghorn: Not just any sausage. None of that turkey stuff for me.. This would have to be beef sausage in a round patty cooked well done so it looks like a hockeypuck. 2 patties.
Waiter: Yes, we can do that. ....
Foghorn:
Waiter: Will that be all then ?
Foghorn: Biscuit
Waiter: You want a biscuits too?
Foghorn: Biscuit... One..Lightly toasted.. Not too brown.. You break it in half horizontally with a fork, then lay one hockypuck on each half. Butter served on the side.
Waiter: OK, I have one biscuit and two sausage patties; will that be all?
Foghorn: Gravy.. Milk gravy with sausage bits in it. You put a good scoop of warm sausage gravy on top of everything and serve it.
Waiter: OK, so you’d like Sausage and Gravy with one biscuit and two sausage patties, covered in gravy. That will be...........
Foghorn: For all of that, the cost is merely one dollar and fifty cents. You’ll find that your company is running it as a senior special through the month of July
Waiter: Oh..Oh..ok..... One senior biscuits and gravy.. Thanks. Ill be right back with that...
The dialogue above took longer to hear than it took me to order my pancakes, get them cooked and eat them all. Sausages included. I tossed the poor kid an extra dollar on my tip because I didnt think the quarter he got from the old codger was going to cover the time lost listening to him.
[Editorial note: Yay! I thought this feature was never coming back!]